If you’ve ever searched for a Criminal Defense Lawyer on Google, chances are the first thing you looked at—before even clicking on the website—was the reviews.
You’re not alone.
In today’s digital age, Google My Business (GMB) reviews often play a huge role in shaping our decisions. Whether you’re choosing a restaurant, a dentist, or something far more critical—like a Criminal Defense Attorney—those stars and snippets of text matter. But when it comes to legal services, not all reviews tell the whole story.
At My Rights Law – Criminal, DUI, and Injury Lawyers, we’re committed to transparency, and we believe that understanding how to interpret online reviews can help you choose the right attorney—whether you’re facing charges for domestic violence, drug crimes, theft, or DUI.
The Role of Google Reviews in Criminal Defense Searches
Google reviews can give potential clients a quick first impression of a law firm. For someone looking for a Domestic Violence Attorney, or urgently needing a DUI Lawyer, seeing dozens of glowing reviews may offer peace of mind.
But here’s the problem: not all reviews reflect the reality of legal representation.
Let’s unpack what you can trust—and what you need to look at with a critical eye.
✅ What You Can Trust in Google Reviews
1. Patterns Across Multiple Reviews
If several clients mention a lawyer’s responsiveness, courtroom presence, or case outcomes, those repeated themes are usually a good sign. For example, if ten people say their Drug Crimes Attorney was aggressive in fighting charges and secured favorable outcomes, that’s probably reliable.
2. Detailed, Case-Specific Feedback
Look for reviews that clearly mention the type of case:
- “They helped me with a complicated DUI with drugs case.”
- “My Domestic Violence Lawyer stood by me through every hearing.”
- “I was facing a serious theft charge, and they got it reduced.”
These kinds of comments are harder to fake and often reflect genuine client experiences.
3. Client Interaction and Response
Law firms that actively respond to reviews—both positive and negative—demonstrate professionalism and a commitment to client service. It shows they care, even when feedback is critical.
❌ What You Shouldn’t Rely on Blindly
1. Anonymous or Vague Reviews
If you see a five-star rating with just a “Great job!” and no context, take it with a grain of salt. In the world of legal defense, especially in emotionally charged cases like sex crimes or domestic violence, clients who leave honest reviews usually have something meaningful to say.
2. Overly Generic Praise
Phrases like “Best lawyer ever!” or “Highly recommend!”—without mentioning what kind of case was involved—don’t provide helpful information. A Criminal Lawyer who handles complex DUI Defense should have reviews that reflect that expertise.
3. Suspiciously High Volume in a Short Time
If a law firm suddenly has 20 new five-star reviews in a week and none before, that could be a red flag. Authentic reviews tend to come in gradually, as clients go through and finish their cases.
Why Reviews Alone Aren’t Enough When Choosing a Criminal Defense Lawyer
Google reviews are useful, but they’re just one piece of the puzzle. You’re not choosing a pair of shoes—you’re choosing someone who will potentially fight to keep you out of jail, protect your reputation, or secure compensation after a serious injury.
Here’s what you also need to consider:
- Experience in your type of case: Whether you need a Sex Crimes Lawyer, Theft Attorney, or DUI Defense Lawyer, make sure the attorney has deep experience in that specific area.
- Local courtroom knowledge: A Car Accident Lawyer who knows your local courts and judges can often resolve injury cases more efficiently.
- Communication and transparency: Reviews might say a lawyer was “great,” but did they return calls? Explain legal options clearly? That’s something to ask during your consultation.
- Track record of results: Look for specific wins, such as reduced charges, dismissed cases, or favorable settlements—especially in cases involving DUI with drugs, domestic violence, or personal injury.
How My Rights Law Earns and Maintains Real Client Trust
At My Rights Law, we don’t chase stars—we earn them.
Whether you’re facing your first DUI, being investigated for a drug offense, or need a Personal Injury Attorney after a truck accident, we take a results-driven, client-first approach. Our reviews reflect real cases, real people, and real outcomes. We believe that reputation should be based on performance, not just page rankings.
We represent clients across a wide range of cases, including:
- Criminal Defense: From misdemeanor theft to felony drug charges
- Domestic Violence Defense
- Sex Crimes and Assault Cases
- DUI and Drunk Driving Charges
- Personal Injury and Accident Claims: Including Car, Motorcycle, and Truck Accidents
Final Thoughts: Read the Reviews, But Ask the Right Questions Too
Google reviews can point you in the right direction, but they shouldn’t be your only guide. When your freedom, your future, or your finances are on the line, trust your instincts—and ask the hard questions.
Better yet, give us a call at My Rights Law - Criminal, DUI, and Injury Lawyers. We’ll give you honest answers, real support, and a solid defense—no review necessary.